The Electric Commentary

Wednesday, May 18, 2005

McArdle on Obesity Among the Poor

Megan McArdle takes this quote from a NYT article:

It's like diffusion of innovation: whenever innovation comes along, the well-to-do are much quicker at adopting it. On the lower end, various disadvantages have piled onto the poor. Diet has gotten worse. There's a lot more work stress. People have less time, if they're poor, to devote to health maintenance behaviors when they are juggling two jobs. Mortality rates even among the poor are coming down, but the rate is not anywhere near as fast as for the well-to-do. So the gap has increased.


and tears it apart:

There's a lot wrong with this. some of this isn't true--in America, the rich work longer hours than the poor, and a postal worker is less likely to have a stressful job than an investment banker. And note the use of the passive voice: "Diet has gotten worse". It's like how in Spanish, no one ever breaks everything; everyone says "se rompio. Diets have gotten worse because poor people are eating crappy food, not because the diet fairy left them with the pork rinds rich people didn't want.

[Doesn't the poor quality of inner-city markets make good food hard to get?-ed. I shop at a market in a housing project, and while it's not exactly Wegmans, I manage to put together a balanced diet on a budget so tight the nickels squeak. Plus, as the man says, "diets have gotten worse", but supermarkets, even in poor areas are only getting better. People are eating fattier, more sugary diets because as food has gotten cheaper, they have chosen to consume more of the things that aren't good for us.]

This is nitpicking, but that quote is absolutely typical of the way obesity among the poor is presented in the media: low-income people are framed as hapless victims rather than agents. This is bad for two reasons. First, it distorts people's beliefs about what sorts of policy interventions are likely to succeed--if you believe the average news article, it would be easy to decide that the best way to lick obesity would be to air-lifting rhubarb and radishes into East New York, and pay doctors to harangue people. Whereas if you spend some time with actual people in, say, assisted housing, you'll find that they, like everyone else know

a) what makes you fat
b) that being fat is unhealthy
c) that you can easily buy fresh fruit if you cut out the slurpees

They're not stupid, and they're not particularly ignorant, though they're probably not as up on the ins-and-outs of saturated fats and Omega-3's as your average food-obsessed young professional. They are choosing to eat the way they do.


The whole post is quite good.

1 Comments:

  • Physical fitness and Work out Forestall Disease

    Fitness and Exercise Forestall disease. That is a proven fact, and yet more Americans than ever so are suffering from obesity and type two diabetes are regarded an epidemic in the United Sates of America. If you are heavy, and especially if you are obese, or if you have been diagnosed with diabetes, then take heed to your doctor and start a steady Fitness and Exercise program. You will be happy you did.

    One of the rewards of Physical fitness and Exercise, as any physician will tell you, it that Fitness and Exercise aid moderate blood sugar. A diabetic who takes medication every day may find that less medicine is needed with a regular Fitness and Exercise plan. Many diabetics who stay with Physical fitness and Work out software online find that they are able to quit the medicine and get their diabetes under moderate in a entirely instinctive manner.

    Triglycerides are also too high for most Americans. High triglycerides are associated to heart disease, including heart attacks and strokes. A wonderful instinctive manner to cut back your level of triglycerides is to simply start and stick with a Fitness and Work out plan, while eating a reasonable diet. Triglycerides at too high a level are also linked to high blood sugar, and it is most common for diabetics to have high triglyceride levels. Therefore, in this case Fitness and Exercise can take charge of two likely wellness hazards at the equivalent time.

    Many people have marveled at the manner being over weight has turn into an American manner of living, and wondered what stimulated it. Many steer to sedentary lifestyles, doing work in front of computers, and watching too much television. In addition, Several Americans eat diets high in fat and carbohydrates. Whatever the root causes Physical fitness and Exercise can be a major part of the cure for this problem. Engaging in physical conduct, increasing the heart pace, and just getting active can aid a person loose weight, moderate triglyceride levels and better diabetes and should not be ignored. Parents should restrict time spent by children with video games or viewing television and promote them to engage in Physical fitness and Exercise the way youngsters in preceding generations have, taking on games like baseball, basketball and skip rope children who learn the benefits of Fitness and Work out at an early age will grow into grownups, who relish Fitness and Exercise, lead healthier lifestyles and tend to live longer, healthier and apparently more euphoric lifetimes.

    Your #1 Resource for Raw Food Seminars

    SEO Solutions and one way link publicity services provided by LinkAcquire.

    David C Skul - CEO LinkAcquire.com and Relativity, Inc. can provide global market exposure and solutions.

    By Blogger David Skul, at 2:23 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home


 
Search:
Keywords:
Amazon Logo